OK, so we at least have all of our submissions for question 1 in, so let's go ahead and get started. I know pretty much everyone knows everyone, but as way of introduction in addition to me we have Mike Smith (who most people know as Christy's brother), Eric Weir (a friend of ours from college), and Becky DeForest (a friend of ours from high school) participating. I presented a total of 5 questions to each member of the panel and asked them to craft responses of around 100 words each. All involved have conceded that this is far more challenging than it first appears to be. The responses are not meant to be exhaustive and complete, but rather jumping off points for discussion and debate. As such, everyone else reading (which is, um, probably like 3 of you) are invited to comment on any/all of our responses as well as contribute your own.
One final note before we get to it is that no one read anyone else's responses (inculding me) prior to responding so any similarities are coincidental. Also, all I did was copy and paste the responses into here, so all emphasis and any typos/incoherence is the creation of the original authors. Now, on with question 1:
Who do you think was the most positively influential person in the last 100 years? I say positively in the sense that you believe the world is better off because of them (i.e. Stalin and Hitler were quite influential, but not in a good way).
John:
Albert Einstein. It’s true that many of his ideas contributed far more to the realm of academia than to the day to day life of the majority of the world’s population (when was the last time the theory of relativity affected your life?). But I think his biggest contribution and legacy is that of the celebrity scientist. He dispelled the image of the stuffy, sterile researcher and showed that it was possible to have genuine passion for math and science and to have those complement, rather than restrict, your imagination. He dedicated his life to learning and wasn’t afraid to alter his positions when the facts demanded it. His contribution in inspiring young minds to pursue math and science and to solve the seemingly unsolvable is immeasurable.
Mike:
In researching this question, I checked out the Time Magazine “100 most important people of the century” article from a few years ago as a starting point. So I started tearing apart their list. No sports figures, politicians or royals (Princess Diana… C’mon!), and no entertainers. All those people are pretty much full of it anyway, and to say the have had great influence would sadden me way too much to go on living.
So that leaves science, medicine, and business as the only PURE categories of people to make my list. My pick is Albert Einstein for his many contributions to Physics and Mathematics, and his views on politics and religion.
Eric:
Muhammad Yunus has applied microcredit to enable the poor to borrow small amounts of money for the purpose of creating new, or upgrading existing, small businesses. Since its inception in 1976, his Grameen Bank has grown to include 1,181 branches with a staff of 11,777. They have collectively loaned $3.9 billion with a recovery rate of 98%, or $3.6 billion. More than 94% of loans have gone to women, who suffer disproportionately from poverty. Grameenphone, an offshoot of the bank, has brought cell-phone ownership to 260,000 rural poor since 1997. In 2006, he was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize.
Note: The loan statistics referenced above were taken from Yunus’ 1999 book Banker to the Poor. Wikipedia cites total Grameen loans at $6.38 billion to 7.4 million borrowers as of July 2007.
Becky:
I’m going to have to go with Henry Ford. He streamlined and popularized mass production, which changed the face of American industry. Plus, his serviceable (with interchangable parts!), affordable Model T's changed the way average Americans lived, traveled, and worked. The argument could even be made that the network of highways that were constructed to handle the boom of automobile traffic was a stepping stone for the telecommunications industry.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

17 comments:
Other people I was debating about:
Reagan (Tear down this wall!)
J. C. R. Licklider (Invented the Internet)
Tim Berners-Lee (Invented the world wide web)
Bill Gates (Brought an easy to use UI to personal computing. also administers a $38.7 billion charity)
Donald Henderson (Led the "Smallpox Eradication Unit")
...others...
Well, good choices from everyone, except John. What were you thinking?
Idiot.
Anyway, just wanted to post my favorite Russert moment
Weir, I had Bill Gates and Tim Berners-Lee on my list too. Was also thinking about Nikola Tesla (invented radio, plus developed the AC electric current we use today) and Alexander Flemming (discovered pennicilin).
This was a rough homework assignment. I had to do research and everything!
Ug, I misspelled penicillin. Ew. Pay no attention.
John:
You should have narrowed that question down in order to avoid some of these dubious responses. What does a Hindu have to do to get on this list? Earn independence for his massive country through nonviolent measures? Check-Gandhi. I mean really, no mention of MLK? I would like you to develop a much more poignant question so I can read some better answers.
Dan are you just trying to get back at me for ripping you on your blog? MLK was huge for America but I don't think he has the global influence, and he was so influenced by Gandhi that you'd be pretty much obligated to go with Gandhi over him. And Gandhi was strongly considered, but in the end I stand by Einstein over him. Another one I strongly considered was Edison, but felt that in the end that was a cop out since even though he didn't die till 1931 the vast majority of his contributions were in the 19th century.
Remember that the question wasn't "who is the only person that mattered in the 20th century"? Obviously any kind of ranking system like this is an apples to oranges comparison and is more telling about the values and biases of the responder than anything else. But then, that's what makes it interesting.
Please John, don't give yourself that much credit. I felt the question was a little too open-ended to foster any type of interesting or beneficial conversation. I wasn't "getting back at you". Keep in mind, I'm one of the 3 d.a.'s you referred to that reads this thing.
I didn't do any research or reference a list for help, but these are my thoughts. The most influential nation in the world is America, creating both positive and negative influences. We drive the global economy, we are the predominent trend setter in civilized nations, and we are the most involved military presense world wide. Therefore I think the most positively influential person has to be from American history. The biggest turning point in our nations history over the last 100 years was climbing out of the great depression. It was an era that tested Americas fortitude. It tested the economic and political structures that defined America and seperated us from all other nations. The ideals of capitalism and democracy were questioned world wide, and it lead to communism and dictatorships taking footholds in Russia and Europe. FDR began his presidency during the depression. He served 3 terms (or was it 4?) and is best know for his New Deal, which created things like the SEC, social security (which has been raped by our modern politicians), and massive public works projects. His radio speeches laid the groundwork for our 24/7 political coverage. His decision to not automatically intervene against Germany's invasions throughout Europe allowed America to rebuild it's military force to a level that eventually beat Hitler (had we done what we do now (instantly involve ourselves) we would have been crushed by Hitler and our history books would have been completely different). The middle class was created during his presidency, allowing massive amounts of poor Americans to live better lives. (Can you tell I have been to his DC memorial?)
Dan, well hopefully you will like my other 4 questions better. I tried to come up with a breadth of topics and also things I hadn't already blogged about. I will admit that the driving force behind this question for me was that I recently finished Einstein's biography and wanted to write about him.
Balld, FDR is a good call. You're over the 100 words though. j/k
I agree with all of your choices, including Balld's unofficial roundtable entry!
I would mention Ghandi and what about Mother Theresa? Just sayin'...
Fuck Oprah.
OK, I pasted my entry into word and broke out the editing pen. I started at 262 words and got it down to 198. There is no way I could make a decent point in 100 words.
On a side note, I had over a dozen speeling and grammer errors. How embarrassing.
Being the auditor that I am, I went and put everyone's post through a word count. John - 127 words. Mike - 112 words. Weir - 99 words (not including his side note). Becky - 69 words.
Balld, while I think you drastically overestimate the role of America on the world stage, you can't possibly claim that those things were true in the 30's and 40's. Also, FDR's social programs were supposed to be temporary measures to pull the country out of depression, unfortunately they have lasted 70 years instead of 10. Also, if we hadn't stopped them on the Eastern front, Russia would have done the job on the Western and saved everybody's asses.
I'm sure people have issues with my choice, but I will voice my opinions about theirs now.
Einstein: I'm sure there are some, and that entire fields of science were created out of his works and theories, but I can't think of a single thing he invented. You want someone who inspired millions to keep studying math and science and is a goofy bastard, and created a product that people actually use, you can go with Bill Gates. Course, not many college kids have Gates posters hanging in their dorm rooms, while I can surely remember many with the Einstein sticking out his tongue poster. Oh, and he helped to invent The Bomb. Good one.
Henry Ford: Ford's claim to inventing the assembly line doesn't hold much water with me. I create mini assembly lines every day. Think if you are sending out thank you notes or invitations or resumes. You don't write one, address the envelope, stuff it, and stamp it. You write them all, address ALL the envelopes, stuff them ALL, and stamp them ALL. Little mini assembly line.
I thought about MLK, but then I also thought that he didn't really do many tangible things. He inspired people, and forced existing laws to be upheld, but I need to hold something in my hands to judge it, and it is just intangible to me since it came WAY before I was born.
I don't know anything about Ghandi. I didn't even see the movie.
And you're letting these things go by too quick. People only respond to the first blog on your page, as soon as you post something else the previous one is forgotten. Slow it down so we can discuss these things a little bit.
Weir,
A) I was not implying that America was all those things 70 years ago, I was saying that those things are the case today, and in order to truly appreciate it you have to know that it was once at the brink of death.
2)It is not FDR's fault that future leaders did not do away with certain aspects of his New Deal.
III) I think you have your fronts mixed up. And Russia may have been able to stop them from expanding east, but they had already taken over most of Europe and no one was willing and or successful to help out those nations.
I think that Fritz Haber has possibly had the most far reaching invention in the last 100 years. Without this process we would live a much less populated world and there would be many places of the world that would not be able to feed themselves.
haber
You want an invention that saved lives? How about the dwarf-wheat?
This is the guy that did it.
He is credited with saving A BILLION lives. A freaking billion. Think that would work as a pick up line? "Hey, I saved a billion Indians from starvation. Wanna buy me a drink?"
Just wanted to quickly revisit this, since I just read about something interesting. Might have to change my answer to Robert Adler, who invented perhaps the greatest product of all time - the tv remote.
Post a Comment